GeneratePress vs. Astra Theme 2022: Honest Comparison Based on Real Tests

GeneratePress vs Astra

Are you Stuck between GeneratePress and Astra theme? Don’t worry; you’re not the only one. I’ve been there, and I’ve had to make decisions with my blog too. This guide will help you choose the suitable WordPress theme for your website today.

GeneratePress vs. Astra theme. Whew.

I’ve used both WordPress themes on my sites over the years. Based on my personal experience of using both themes, you get all the facts you need to know before using them on your website.

And to be clear, there is plenty of other WordPress themes out there beyond just these two. But when it comes to choosing the best WordPress theme for bloggers specifically, only a select few of them rise to the top of the line, and I’ve tested many alternatives myself, like NewsPaper, Divi, Avada, etc.

We’re left with a decision between my favorite WordPress themes: GeneratePress vs. Astra. The best part? Both themes offer free plans to get started.

GeneratePress vs Astra Theme Comparison 2021

I want to start this guide off by making it ultra-clear that I use GeneratePress as my main WordPress theme of choice (as a blogger).

I firmly believe both are hands down the best fastest-loading WordPress theme for bloggers today. If you want to try them out risk-free, you can start with their free version today to give it a real test run for yourself.

I’ll be the first to tell you, though, no single WordPress theme is going to be the absolute best fit for everyone. 

And it might make more sense for you to select other WordPress themes depending upon your blogging needs. If you are looking for a theme for AdSense websites, then Newspaper is probably the best choice for you. 

How to Choose Which WordPress theme is Right for You?

Selecting a WordPress theme is always hard for new website owners. There are tons of things you need to consider before choosing your WordPress theme. WordPress theme design not only affects your user’s experience but also impacts your revenue.

Below are a few aspects I looked at to find the best WordPress themes:

1:) Speed: Speed is one of the critical aspects you need to consider first. No one likes slow loading websites; even Google announced website speed is essential for ranking a website. Your website theme must be thoroughly optimized for speed; it improves users’ experience and enhances on-page SEO.

2:) Simplicity or Complexity: Theme functionality is essential to consider. Not everyone is a techy nerd; your theme should be easily customizable, like changing a few settings, colors, fonts, etc.

3:) Site Responsiveness: Your site looks good on a 16” laptop, and it’s doesn’t mean your site also looks good on a small-sized smartphone. Smartphone traffic increases every year; a responsive theme is essential for everyone. Before buying any theme, make sure it’s 100% responsive for any screen size. And remember, Google has made it mandatory for every website to be mobile responsive & the latest Browser supported.

4:) Page Builders Support: With a drag & drop page builder, you can easily create beautiful-looking website designs without any coding knowledge. Most WordPress themes support page builders, but not all of them do. If you want to create a beautiful-looking website, the theme must be comfortable with leading page builders like Elementor, Beaver Builder, etc.

5:) Pricing: The last aspect to think about is whether you should use a free or premium WordPress theme. The difference isn’t just in the pricing, and the premium version theme comes with a lot’s theme functionality, customization options, & support.

How much does the WordPress theme cost for your blog?

When you’re just starting a blog, your costs for a WordPress theme should be meager (or even free). Don’t worry. Both themes are freely available at WordPress repository with overall 5.0 ratings by users.

Now, let’s break down all of the actual costs for both WordPress themes to unlock their full potential.

GeneratePress vs Astra Pricing Breakdown (2021 Updated):

Here’s a chart that breaks down the pricing comparison of the GeneratePress theme vs Astra theme.

FeaturesGeneratePressAstra Theme
Site Installation500Unlimited
Free VersionAvailableAvailable
Site LibaryYesYes
Customer SupportYesYes
Overall Rating5.0/5.05.0/5.0
Active users400,000+1+ million
Page BuilderSupportedSupported
DiscountClaim NowClaim Now

Now, let’s dive into a complete detailed analysis of both of our WordPress themes to compare GeneratePress vs Astra.

GeneratePress Analysis, Feature Breakdown and Performance

GeneratePress is one of the most popular fast-loading multi-purpose themes out there. It’s rating in the WordPress repository is one of the highest, with 1227 out of 1247 reviews giving it a 5-star rating, and it has 400,000+ active installs.

Generatepress theme

GeneratePress theme is known for having clean code, being super lightweight out of the box, and flexibility with all page builders. The entire GeneratePress theme size is only 30kb when installed, while the average WordPress theme size is over 1MB.

Below are some notable features you need to know before you use GeneratePress on your website:

Which Features Does GeneratePress Have?
  • Super fast & lightweight design with no jQuery dependency.
  • Fully mobile responsive and looks great across all devices.
  • Built-in Schema features for better results in SERPs.
  • Impressive integration with the WordPress deafult Customizer.
  • Compatible with all popular WordPress plugins, Yoast SEO, WooCommerce, Rank Math SEO, BuddyPress, UpDraftPus, and WPML.
  • Perfectly optimzed for all popular page builders like Elementor and Beaver Builder.
  • Translation & RTL ready.
  • 100% accessible.
  • Compete theme documentation available.
  • Tons of developer frindly hooks, elements, and filters.
  • Awesome customer support from an involved developer.

Along with all features, GeneratePress premium user gets all premium modules to control everything on your website:

GeneratePress premium modules

Note: With a combination of the GeneratePress Premium and free GenerateBlocks plugin, you can visually build every aspect of your website from search without touching a line of code. This site is also made using the GeneratePress premium & GenerateBlock block editor plugin.

What are the Drawbacks of GeneratePress?

There are no significant drawbacks of the GeneratePress theme except one. Free GeneratePress theme has lots of customization restrictions & a lack of support on the free version. You have to buy a GeneratePress premium add-on to get developer support & a complete customization option.

How Much Does GeneratePress Cost in 2021?

Core GeneratePress theme is 100% free for everyone and is available at GeneratePress Premium is technically a WordPress plugin that you install alongside with free theme, and the GeneratePress Premium plugin extends the theme functionality & customization options.

GeneratePress premium pricing

GeneratePress Premium is available at an affordable price of $59 yearly and $249 for lifetime updates. 

For $59, you get all 14 premium modules, can use it on up to 500 sites, and one year of support and regular updates. It’s definitely worth the money, and I’ve moved all of my sites to GeneratePRess. Only $59 for a premium theme is a steal!

If you plan to save more money, you can get a GeneratePress lifetime deal for $249. Like a yearly plan, this plan only includes lifetime updates and support. You can also upgrade from the annual plan to the lifetime plan anytime you want.

GeneratePress premium version will get access to their All premium modules, Full access to the Site Library, 500 website usages, regular theme updates, premium support, & a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Have a look at GeneratePress Premium Plans Pricing

Astra Theme Analysis, Feature Breakdown and Performance

Created by Brainstorm Force, Wp Astra is a fast, fully customizable & beautiful multi-purpose WordPress theme. Astra is one of the most popular WordPress themes that can be used for portfolios, blogs, businesses, WooCommerce storefronts, and more.

Astra theme

The Astra theme is the 3rd most prevalent theme in the official WordPress repository. The free Astra theme version is used on more than 1,500,000 websites and has maintained an excellent 5-star rating on over 4800 reviews.

Astra theme built for Performance optimization; with default WordPress data, Astra should load in less than half a second and take resources under 50kb by disabling jQuery. Below are some Astra theme features & premium modules details:

Which Features Does Astra Have?
  • Perfectly compatible with all popular page builder plugins including Elementor, Beaver Builder, Thrive Architect, and others.
  • Developer friendly themes. With Astra theme, you can easily hooks and filters, it is super-easy for developers to extend the functionality.
  • Astra theme includes hundreds of pre-built demo website that you can import on your website with just one clicks.
  • Astra theme use Self hosted Google fonts. It will load your font faster and improve the Core Web Vitals performance.
  • Astra uses latest Vanilla JavaScript that prevents render blocking jQuery. As a result, it improve your website overall performance.
  • With Astra theme, you can easily Custom Fonts with just a free plugin.
  • 24/7 Support with in-depth articles & video tutorials for begginers.
  • Astra comes with the basic schema markup implementation. For advance schema intregration you can check their Schema Pro.
  • Popular Third party plugins support.

Astra is a multi-purpose WordPress theme, and it’s straightforward to customize the theme with the default WordPress customizer. This also comes with a performance optimization tab to optimize your Google fonts by preloading them.

Astra theme default customization options

With the help of Astra Pro Addon, you get access to over 19 different premium modules to save a ton of time designing work your website.

Astra Pro customization option

Note: Along with the Astra theme Brainforce team also offer different types of Page builder extension to enhance visual page builders’ capabilities. If you use Elemetor page builder on your website, you can check their Ultimate addons for Elementor. For Beaver builder, then you need Ultimate addons for Beaver builder.

What are the Drawbacks of Astra?

Astra is perfect with only one downside, like the GeneratePress theme. It would help if you used the Astra Pro add-on to customize everything on your website and the developer support option is not available on the free Astra version.

How Much Does Astra Cost in 2021?

Like GeneratePress theme, Astra theme also offers a 100% free version on the WordPress repository. To use Astra theme exclusive features & customization options, you need to install the Astra Pro plugin.

Astra has three license options to unlock the Astra theme premium version. The Astra Pro plans cost $59 per year, the Essential Bundle costs $276 per year, and the Growth Bundle costs $523 per year. 

With all Astra Premium plans, you get access to all Astra Pro Add-ons, Free Starter Templates, 24/7 support, unlimited website usages, regular updates, etc.

Astra Pro Pricing

The best part about Astra Premium is you get 30% with all plans with our special discount coupon link. It means you get Astra pro at $47/year, Essential bundle at $169/year, & Growth bundle at $249/year. 

Which Astra plans to choose? What’s the difference?

Astra Pro Plan: Astra Pro is a plugin that only unlocks all features of the Astra theme with 20+ starter templates.

Essential Bundle Plan: Astra Essential plan comes with Astra pro Addons with Premium Wp Portfolio plugin, 180+ premium starter themes, and One Page Builder Add-on (Ultimate Add-ons for Elementor / Ultimate Add-ons for Beaver Builder).

Growth Bundle Plan: Astra Growth Bundle comes with everything the Brainstorm Force team offers. Including all premium plugins like Convert Pro Plugin, Schema Pro Plugin, Ultimate Add-ons for Beaver Builder, Ultimate Addons for Elementor, Premium starter templates, and $1199 worth SkileJet academy membership for free.

Which Astra Plan to choose?

In a nutshell, if you are looking for Astra theme complete customizations options & premium add-ons, go for Astra Pro Add-on. And If you want to use a single page builder enhance tool with premium starter templates, go for the Astra Essential Bundle plan. And choose the Astra Growth Bundle plan if you want every premium plugin, starter template, premium support.

Note: All Astra premium plans come with a 14-day 100% money-back guarantee. It means, If you purchase Astra PRO and are not satisfied with theme performance, then you can get your money back within 14 days.

Have a look at Astra Premium Plans Pricing. (Discount applied automatically)

GeneratePress vs Astra: Performance Comparison (Load Times + Speed Test)

Performance is a key metric you should know before selecting your website theme. I always test WordPress themes right out of the box without customizations and cache plugins. For theme performance testing, I prefer CloudWays Hosting with PHP 8.

We installed each theme on a fresh WordPress install to test both themes’ performance and ran tests with different speed tools checkers (GtMetrix, Tools Pingdom, & Byte Check).

Here’s our result:

GeneratePress theme performance:

GtMetrix Speed Test

  • PageSpeed Score: 99%
  • YSlow Score: 96%
  • Load Time: 1.1s
  • Page Size: 34.5KB
  • Requests: 8

Pingdom Speed Test:

  • Performance Grade: 97
  • Load Time: 485ms
  • Page Size: 37.9KB
  • Requests: 8

Byte Check TTFB Test

  • TTFB: 126ms
  • Total Time: 526ms
  • Request Size: 201b
  • Header Size: 420b
Astra theme performance:

GtMetrix Speed Test

  • PageSpeed Score: 99%
  • YSlow Score: 96%
  • Load Time: 1.3s
  • Page Size: 47.9KB
  • Requests: 9

Pingdom Speed Test:

  • Performance Grade: 96
  • Load Time: 405ms
  • Page Size: 45.9KB
  • Requests: 10

Byte Check TTFB Test

  • TTFB: 131ms
  • Total Time: 526ms
  • Request Size: 201b
  • Total Header Size: 407b

Performance conclusion:

Both GeneratePress and Astra are more performance-optimized than average WordPress themes available WordPress repository, and both themes can get you a fast-loading website.

Overall, though, GeneratePress is a little bit ahead in our performance test in different test tools, though the difference isn’t huge (Only a few milliseconds). Still, if you’re looking for the fastest WordPress theme, you can use GeneratePress.

After using the GeneratePress theme with Kinsta Managed WordPress hosting with WP Rocket cache plugin, here’s my website result.

WordPress website performance

To get perfect performance results on your website, you also need a fast hosting provider (Recommend: CloudWays), cache plugin (Recommend: Wp Rocket), and image optimization plugin (Recommend: ShortPixel)

So, What’s the Best WordPress theme for Bloggers in 2021?

The honest answer is… it depends.

Both GeneratePress & Astra theme has their strengths and can be the right fit for different use-cases.

I use the GeneratePress theme on this site. Still, I believe strongly that Astra is by far the best WordPress theme for at least somewhat established bloggers, and the addition of their free theme makes them a pretty unbeatable force in the WordPress theme community.

For that reason, Astra is the #1 WordPress theme I recommend today, even for brand-new bloggers to start with from day one; thanks for a free WordPress theme.

I recommend you to use the premium version of this theme to get complete theme control, premium add-ons, & pre-made site layouts. 

GeneratePress offers 30 days, and Astra theme provides 14 days refund policy. After using GeneratePress or Astra theme premium version, you get your money back if you are not satisfied with the performance. So, NO risk is involved.

Try GeneratePress Premium | Try Astra Pro

If you use GeneratePress or Astra theme, share your thoughts on comment sections for other users. Are there any other questions related to Astra vs. GeneratePress that would help you make your decision? Let me know in the comments!

We hope this article helped you find a suitable WordPress theme for your website needs. For more information, please look at our complete GeneratePress theme review or our Astra theme review.

Read more about:

I hope you liked my GeneratePress vs. Astra comparison.

Thank You. Have a nice day.

Leave a Comment